Blog
The Psychotherapy Practice Research Network (PPRNet) blog began in 2013 in response to psychotherapy clinicians, researchers, and educators who expressed interest in receiving regular information about current practice-oriented psychotherapy research. It offers a monthly summary of two or three published psychotherapy research articles. Each summary is authored by Dr. Tasca and highlights practice implications of selected articles. Past blogs are available in the archives. This content is only available in English.
This month...
…I blog about therapist empathy, psychotherapeutic treatment for borderline personality disorder, and research on psychological treatment of depression.
Type of Research
Topics
- ALL Topics (clear)
- Adherance
- Alliance and Therapeutic Relationship
- Anxiety Disorders
- Attachment
- Attendance, Attrition, and Drop-Out
- Client Factors
- Client Preferences
- Cognitive Therapy (CT) and Cognitive-Behavioural Therapy (CBT)
- Combination Therapy
- Common Factors
- Cost-effectiveness
- Depression and Depressive Symptoms
- Efficacy of Treatments
- Empathy
- Feedback and Progress Monitoring
- Group Psychotherapy
- Illness and Medical Comorbidities
- Interpersonal Psychotherapy (IPT)
- Long-term Outcomes
- Medications/Pharmacotherapy
- Miscellaneous
- Neuroscience and Brain
- Outcomes and Deterioration
- Personality Disorders
- Placebo Effect
- Practice-Based Research and Practice Research Networks
- Psychodynamic Therapy (PDT)
- Resistance and Reactance
- Self-Reflection and Awareness
- Suicide and Crisis Intervention
- Termination
- Therapist Factors
- Training
- Transference and Countertransference
- Trauma and/or PTSD
- Treatment Length and Frequency
August 2023
Therapists Tend to Overestimate their Effectiveness
Constantino, M. J., Boswell, J. F., Coyne, A. E., Muir, H. J., Gaines, A. N., & Kraus, D. R. (2023). Therapist perceptions of their own measurement-based, problem-specific effectiveness. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 91(8), 474–484. https://doi.org/10.1037/ccp0000813
Previous research showed that therapists may be over-confident about their effectiveness. In one study, 91% of therapists felt that they were more effective than 75% of their peers, and 100% of therapists felt that they were more effective than 50% of their peers. These therapist perceptions relative to their peers are statistically impossible. What is the impact of this over-confidence on patient outcomes? In this study, Constantino and colleagues evaluated the perceptions and outcomes of 50 therapists who treated 1,363 patients (about 27 patients per therapist). Most therapists practiced CBT, integrative, or interpersonal psychotherapy. Patients had a variety of problems including depression, anxiety, sleep, social functioning, etc. Patients self-report of symptoms in 12 problem domains (depression, anxiety, etc.) from pre to post treatment. Therapists were asked to report on their perception of their effectiveness by rating from “mostly effective” to “mostly ineffective” for each patient problem domain. Then therapists’ ratings of their effectiveness were compared to their patients’ actual measurement-based outcomes from pre- to post-treatment. In this manner, therapists were classified as accurately estimating their outcomes, or as underestimating their outcomes, or as overestimating their outcomes compared to their patients’ outcome data. The researchers also controlled for case mix (complexity and size of the therapists’ caseload) and patient symptom severity at pre-treatment. For 7 of 12 patient problem domains, at least half of the therapists overestimated their own effectiveness. For the remaining 5 domains, most therapists accurately estimated their effectiveness. There were no domains for which most therapists underestimated their effectiveness. In 11 of the 12 patient problems, therapists were no better than chance at predicting their own effectiveness compared to patient rating. However, therapists who underestimation their effectiveness had patients with better outcomes at post-treatment, and this effect was stronger for patients with higher pre-treatment symptom severity. Conversely, therapists who overestimated their outcomes had patients with worse outcomes, and this effect was stronger for patients with higher pre-treatment symptom severity.
Practice Implications
Relative to patient self-reported measurement-based outcomes, therapists tend to be over-confident about their effectiveness. This over-confidence has implications for patients’ outcomes. Patients of therapists who show more humility about their effectiveness (tend to be neutral or under-estimate their effectiveness) have better outcomes. This is particularly true for patients with more severe symptoms. One of the few therapist factors known to predict better outcomes is professional self-doubt - the willingness to critically evaluate one’s practices and to continually improve one’s skills. Self-doubt may allow therapists to be more alert to potential signals that the therapy is off course, that they might have committed a micro-aggression, or that there was a therapeutic alliance rupture. Humility might allow the therapist to flexibly respond, change course, or repair the therapeutic relationship when necessary.
Characteristics of Psychologists Conducting Psychotherapy
Norcross, J. C., Rocha, M. N., & Chrysler, A. A. (2023, May 18). Psychologists conducting psychotherapy in 2022: Contemporary practices and historical patterns of the Society for the Advancement of Psychotherapy. Psychotherapy. Advance online publication. https://dx.doi.org/10.1037/pst0000493
Every 10 years or so the Society for Advancement of Psychotherapy (American Psychological Association, Division 29) conducts a survey of its membership to take a snapshot of their characteristics and activities. The membership is a diverse group of practicing psychotherapists and psychotherapy researchers with doctoral degrees in psychology in the U.S. The Society’s membership is not representative of all psychologists who practice psychotherapy, but the fact that the survey has taken place every decade since 1981 allows one to get a sense of some historical trends in the field. Previous surveys showed an increasingly female and culturally diverse membership. Theoretical orientations have tended to favor psychodynamic and cognitive-behavioral models, and primary employment has shifted from hospitals and community clinics to independent practices and universities. In this survey, Norcross and colleagues randomly selected 1000 members of the Society and received a 48% return rate. 65% were male and 35% were female, and the proportion of women has steadily grown from 27% in 1981. Most of the sample was White (90%). The average age was 68 years (SD = 13), and there has been a steady increase in age since 1981 when the average age was 46. On average, psychologists devoted 44% of their professional time to psychotherapy, 11% to research and writing, and 10% to teaching. There has been a gradual decline in the percentage of psychologists routinely supervising from 65% in 1981 to 37% in 2022. The percentage of psychologists providing diagnosis and assessment also declined from 55% in 2012 to 37% in 2022. Most psychologists (99%) provided individual therapy, but many also provided couple therapy (75%), and group therapy (20%) during some of their professional time. Psychologists working in public hospitals and community clinics continued to decrease from 16% in 1981 to 3% in 2022. In 2022, the most frequent theoretical orientations were psychodynamic/relational (29%), integrative (26%), and cognitive/cognitive-behavioral (CBT; 18%). CBT has steadily increased in popularity from 8% in 1981 to 18% in 2022. Of the respondents, 82% indicated that they received personal therapy at least once during their career. On average, 94% were satisfied at least to some degree with their careers, and 78% indicated that if they had to do it over again, they would choose to pursue a career in psychotherapy.
Practice Implications
This survey is not perfect and it likely is not representative of the population of psychologists who provide psychotherapy. Nevertheless, it does suggest some interesting historical trends. The average psychotherapist in these surveys appears to be getting older over time. This may indicate that younger psychotherapists are not aligning themselves with traditional organizations that provide a community of like-minded professionals. That is unfortunate as it limits the continuing education and supportive networks that could be available to a younger professional. On the positive side, many psychotherapists have pursued personal therapy during their careers and this trend has been consistent over the years. Further most psychotherapists are quite satisfied with their careers despite the stress related to doing this type of work.
June 2023
What People Want From Therapy
Delboy, S. & Michaels, L. (2021). Going beneath the surface: What people want from therapy. Psychoanalytic Inquiry, 41:8, 603-623. DOI: 10.1080/07351690.2021.1992232
There has been an increased interest in and demand for mental health care, and so one can imagine that the public might have questions or opinions about psychotherapy. Moreover, research has shown that patients who get the type of treatment that they expect or want are more likely to have better outcomes. However, it is rare that researchers ask the public what they want from therapy. In this unique study, Delboy and Michaels conducted a survey of US citizens about their perceptions and preferences for psychotherapy. Their sample of 1,535 respondents were deliberately selected to be representative of US census data for age, gender, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, and geographic region. The survey asked what people what they wanted from therapy: 70% indicated that they wanted to “learning skills and coping strategies”, which is like what is offered in manualized treatment modalities. However, 70% also wanted to “better understand oneself and the root of one’s issues”, which is like what is offered in depth, insight, and relational therapies. When forced to choose between a “therapy that takes fewer sessions and helps manage symptoms” and a “therapy that takes longer but addresses the root causes of problems”, 91% chose a longer therapy focused on root causes. Over 60% of the sample indicated that they wanted to “share feelings without judgement” and to “feel heard and understood by someone who cares”, which suggests that people value these qualities in the therapist and the therapeutic relationship. Interestingly, two thirds of the sample recognized that therapy takes time “to understand and resolve” one’s issues and problems. And less than 10% did not want to understand their problems or examine issues from childhood. Regarding the reasons of their mental health issues, 50% reported that relationship patterns are an important source of their distress, whereas only 10% attributed mental health problems to a “chemical imbalance” in the brain.
Practice Implications
Patients tend to do better when they get the treatment that they prefer. A similar percentage of the public (70%) wanted to “learn coping strategies” and to “better understand” themselves. However, when asked to choose, the vast majority (91%) preferred to better understand themselves and to address the root causes of problems. In addition, most people recognized that therapy takes more time than is often offered in time limited treatments. This is consistent with large surveys of patients that indicated that it took over 50 sessions before significant symptom relief was achieved. It is time for insurance providers, clinicians, and training programs to begin to take stock of client preferences when paying for, providing, and training for psychotherapy.
March 2023
Negative Effects of Psychotherapy
Strauss, B., Gawlytta, R., Schleu, A., & Frenzl, D. (2021). Negative effects of psychotherapy: Estimating the prevalence in a random national sample. BJPsych Open, 7(6), E186.
The focus of psychotherapy research tends to be on establishing the effectiveness of psychotherapies for various disorders. Rarely do psychotherapy studies report negative effects or negative outcomes. Some researchers estimate that about 5% of patients experience worsening of symptoms by the end of psychotherapy. However, there are very few investigations of clients’ experiences of the negative impact of therapy and fewer still that ask clients in the general population who had a course of therapy. In this national survey of the general population, Strauss and colleagues asked 5562 individuals if they received psychotherapy in the past 6 years. Of the total sample, 244 indicated that they had or are currently in treatment. These individuals had characteristics similar to patients seen in treatment. The mean age was 55.1 years (SD = 15/2), 63.4% had shorter term therapy of less than a year, 41% reported an anxiety disorder and 77% had a mood disorder, 63.1% saw a female therapist, and 69.2% saw a psychologist. These individuals were asked a series of questions regarding their experiences as clients in therapy. Rates of positive change due to therapy varied by the problems that they noted. For example, 26.6% indicated that they had a better relationship with their parents due to therapy, whereas 67.7% experienced improved mood. On average 88.6% agreed that they had a positive working relationship with the therapist. However, about 19% dropped out of therapy and an additional 13.1% changed therapist during treatment, indicating negative experiences or outcomes. Patient problems that had the highest deterioration rates (i.e., worsened) were physical well-being (13.1%), ability to work (13.1%), vitality (11.1%), sexual problems (10.6%) and problems with self-esteem (10.3%). The most common negative effect attributed to specifically to the treatment was the resurfacing of unpleasant memories (57.8% in the total sample). Other such problems like sleep problems, stress, and unpleasant feelings were reported 27.9% to 36.9% of the time. Of the total sample, 56.6% reported having had at least one negative effect caused by their experience in psychotherapy. Boundary violations and malpractice were very rarely reported by this sample of patients.
Practice Implications
Much of the research and clinical writing of psychotherapy tends to focus on whether it is effective and to document its positive effects. However, an important minority of patients experience worsening of symptoms and/or unpleasant or negative effects of psychotherapy. Some might argue that painful feelings that emerge in some clients is a necessary process when the client works through conflicting feelings or perceptions of themselves and others. A collaborative agreement between therapist and client on how therapy might proceed, how it works, or the goals of therapy will go a long way to limit the negative impact of working through unpleasant feelings in therapy. Nevertheless, therapists should monitor dropout rates in their practice and worsening symptoms in their clients and adjust their therapy and interpersonal stances accordingly.
January 2023
Working Alliance and Therapist Cultural Humility Reduce the Impact of Microaggressions
A lack of culturally competent care can have negative impacts on therapy outcomes for Black, Indigenous, People of Color (BIPOC) and for women who experience discrimination based on gender. Often these negative outcomes occur because of microaggressions – which are a form of alliance rupture in the therapeutic relationship caused by subtle, intentional, or unintentional messages that degrade BIPOC, women, and other historically excluded groups. The majority of BIPOC clients (81%) and women (53%) report experiencing a therapist microaggression over the course of psychotherapy. A therapist’s cultural humility (valuing the importance of culture in their client’s experience) and the therapeutic alliance (client-therapist collaborative agreement on tasks and goals of therapy) may reduce the negative impact of microaggressions committed by the therapist. This study by DeBlaere and colleagues looked at the association between microaggressions experienced by BIPOC women and therapy outcomes, and whether this association was reduced by higher levels of therapist cultural humility and therapeutic alliance. The clients were 288 BIPOC women who were treated by a psychotherapist (81% had a female therapist, and 46% had a White therapist). Both racial and gender microaggressions were associated with worse outcomes. Using structural equation modeling to assess indirect effects, the authors found a significant indirect effect of racial microaggressions (−.12, 95% CI [−.35, −.07]) and gender microaggressions (−.10, 95% CI [−.36, −.05]) on positive therapy outcomes, through both cultural humility and working alliance, accounting for 24% of the variance in outcomes. That is, the effect of microaggressions on outcomes was partly explained by the level of therapist cultural humility and by the therapeutic alliance. The most common racial microaggression reported by clients was: “My counselor avoided discussing or addressing cultural issues in our sessions”, and the most common gender microaggression was: “My therapist encouraged me to be less assertive so that I do not present myself as being aggressive”.
Practice Implications
Unfortunately, therapist racial and gender microaggressions are common. However, therapists who practice cultural humility and who work at developing a therapeutic alliance may commit fewer microaggressions and can more easily mitigate the negative effects of microaggressions should they occur. Taking steps to develop cultural humility, strengthening the alliance, and repairing alliance ruptures through professional development may be ways of improving therapy outcomes for BIPOC women.
Ways to Address Cultural Topics in Psychotherapy
When ethnic minority members receive psychotherapy, they tend to show higher premature drop-out rates. One of the factors associated with these negative outcomes may be that therapists may not know how to effectively address the cultural conversations that inevitably arise with some clients. To help therapists, some authors developed a Multicultural Orientation Framework (MCO) that consists of cultural humility (taking an other-oriented stance regarding culture while remaining non-defensive about one’s own limitations), cultural opportunities (discussing clients’ cultural identities when they emerge in therapy), and cultural comfort (a therapist’s genuine comfort in discussing cultural topics). Such a stance may also help therapists to address microaggressions (intentional or unintentional verbal or behavioral indignities based on cultural identity). One useful therapist stance is “broaching” of culturally sensitive topics – that is, therapists’ engaging in explicit dialogue with clients about culture. Previous research indicates that broaching culturally topics can benefit the therapeutic alliance and clients’ perception of therapist multicultural competence. In this survey study, Depauw and colleagues looked at three aspects of broaching – direct broaching in which a therapist explicitly raises cultural topics (“I noticed that we both have a different ethnic background…), indirect broaching in which a therapist is receptive to cultural topics but with less focused exploration (“…you mentioned your friend doesn’t understand your experiences, are there other situations in which that happened…?”), and avoiding broaching in which a therapist sidesteps cultural conversations even when a client brings them up. Depauw and colleagues surveyed 211 psychotherapy clients in the United Kingdom who identified as not being a member of the predominant social group (i.e., with regard to ethnicity, gender/sexual expression, religion, socioeconomic status, ability, and others). The researchers asked whether therapists broached cultural identity topics, what type of broaching approach a therapist took, and clients also rated their therapist’s level of MCO (cultural comfort, cultural humility, and missed opportunities) and therapist microaggressions. The results revealed that both therapist direct and indirect broaching of cultural topics were favorably associated with a client’s rating of the therapist’s MCO and with fewer microaggressions. Therapists’ avoidance of broaching of cultural topics was associated with negative ratings of therapist MCO and with more microaggressions. When only considering the clients’ most important self-identified cultural identity, the researchers found that indirect broaching was favorably related to all aspects of MCO and fewer microaggression, direct broaching was only associated with fewer missed opportunities, and avoidant broaching was unfavorably related to all aspects of MCO and microaggressions.
Practice Implications
The results of this survey of clients suggest that therapists should not avoid cultural content in therapy. Broaching culturally sensitive topics is important for a good therapeutic experience for clients with diverse identities. In some cases, for clients’ primary cultural identity, indirect broaching of culturally sensitive topics may be more effective. Therapists should consider a client’s identity in terms of how the client experiences it and the importance of the identity to the client.